The Caretaker View Of Children s Rights - 2733 Words

This essay will seek to explain what is meant by the ‘caretaker’ view of children’s rights, after which it’s strengths and weaknesses will be discussed. At first, the ‘caretaker’ thesis will be described and its specific characteristics, such as ‘delayed consent’, will be highlighted. The paper will then move on to discuss the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989), which will reveal that despite children being granted the right to participate, under Article 3 of the Convention all of their decisions are still subject to parental determination. Afterwards, the weaknesses of the ‘caretaker’ approach to children’s rights will be contrasted against the framework of the child liberation movement. Most importantly, it will be argued that the protectionist view displays a misinterpretation of biological factors and their correlation with maturity and competency (Godwin, 2011). The new sociology of childhood will be referenced to outline further wrongdoing of the ‘caretaker view’. It will be argued that children should be seen as individuals rather than a group, therefore their capabilities cannot be judged collectively. Strengths of the protectionist view will be shown through the vast amount of legislation and policy surrounding children, which still is largely based on protectionist values. Additionally, the paper will draw on Sue Palmer’s book ‘Toxic Childhood’ to argue against the participation of children. Overall it can be said that the traditional ‘caretaker’Show MoreRelatedMedication Is A Necessary Aspect Of Being Human1478 Words   |  6 PagesBecause of medication billions of people worldwide are helped. However, there is much more to medicine than helping someone s cold. It saves lives. Medication should be enforced, but only when the health and safety of others is in jeopardy. When one is unable to make their own conscious decisions, medication should be administered with the oversight of a professional and a caretaker. In a situation where a child has a medical condition that requires medication for treatment, the decision on whether thatRead MoreNursing Is A Profession That Will Never Quit Developing1490 Words   |  6 Pageshelp sick individuals. While surveying a patient they check indispensable signs, side effects, and advance in patients. There are a wide range of sorts of medical caretakers, from surgical attendants to office medical caretakers. They all have diverse obligations. The biggest gathering of attendants is healing center medical caretakers. They are relegated to one office and work there, for instance, maternity, surgery, and pediatrics.Most opportunities are provided by traveling nurses to fulfill needsRead MoreFeminism : Women And Women1316 Words   |  6 Pagesbelief that women and men should have equal rights and opportunities. Th e feminist revolution has come a long way, yet women are still being viewed as beneath men. Unfortunately, we are still living in a male dominated society. The work that is done by a man is still being seen as more significant and worthwhile than that of a woman. In society, being a wife and/or mother has been the most significant role of women. Society continues to view women as caretakers and nurturers. Though a woman may work andRead MoreWe Must Prevent Child Abuse1391 Words   |  6 Pagesprioritizing these challenges in order to most effectively solve them. Different groups of people have varying views in terms of what is most important to work on. Due to this disagreement, there is a standstill and some issues are left to grow while they are overshadowed. While the United States government focuses their attention mainly on the economy and foreign affairs, the issue of protecting children from abuse and neglect is an ongoing struggle that needs to be more acknowledged. There are many aspectsRead MoreThe Effects Of Propaganda On Women s Rights1679 Words   |  7 PagesBeijing, China. As the Honorary Chairperson of the United States delegation to the conference, she gave the speech, Women s Rights Are Human Rights in the first few days during a special Plenary Session. In the speech, she utilized several persuasive techniques, also known as propaganda, grasping people s attention in order to achieve support for the claim of the women s rights she was devoted to. Propaganda is usually a speech device that people intently use to induce or intensify others actionsRead MoreGender Identity Has Changed Its Definition Over Time1578 Words   |  7 Pagesworld the definition has broadened. Gender identity is now defined as one s personal experience of one s own gender. Gender identity can correlate with assigned sex at birth, or can differ from it completely. All societies have a set of gender categories that can serve as the basis of the formation of a p erson s social identity in relation to other members of society. From the past when we had many strong women’s rights activist who fought so what your gender was did not define you or what youRead MoreThe Help And Contemporary Social Issues. In Recent Conversation1749 Words   |  7 Pagesloyal, and contented caretakers of whites† Aibileen and Constantine embody these characteristics through the loyalty and genuine love they showed to the white children they raised, although they were also loyal to their own children who had already grown up. Aibileen says that she raised 17 children over the years and Constantine worked for Skeeters family for over 20 years. Even though they both were very loyal to the children of their employers, they still loved their own children and are shown toRead MoreThe Mainstream Media And Gender Inequality Essay1517 Words   |  7 Pagesdiscusses the reality of the pay gap, and how it is especially upsetting when it comes to early childhood education and caretakers. She begins the report by talking about the gross underpay of these workers, saying that sometimes they have a lower salary than parking attendants, janitors, and dog walkers. This isn’t right in of itself, but she turns the argument towards women’s rights when suggesting that the reason these professions are underpaid is because it is mostly women in them. This has existedRead MoreBecoming Members Of Society By Aaron Devor Essay1236 Words   |  5 Pagesnoticeably more feminine than others, and they get treated differently by the majority, such as getting weird looks, getting laugh at, etc. From the moment children are born, they were taught of the ideas of gender. These ideas tell them how they act, look, and think appropriately to their gender roles. An example would be parents giving their children toys and introducing them to colors. Boys are given action figures, building blocks and toy cars. On the other hand, girls get to have tea sets, dollsRead MoreSurrealism, And A New Mode Of Pure Expression1562 Words   |  7 Pagesimportance of merging dream and reality. In Breton’s view, one can learn to ascend to perception of a higher reality (the surreal), or more reality, if one can manage to liberate one’s psyche from traditional education, the drudgery of work, and the dullness of what is only useful in modern bourgeois culture. To achieve the heightened consciousness to which Breton wants humanity to aspire, those interested can also look to the example set by children, poets, and to a lesser extent, insane persons. Though